In the world of competitive Magic: The Gathering, few formats are as beloved as Legacy. With a vast pool of cards to choose from, players can construct a wide range of decks that cater to their unique playstyle. Among these, two dredge variants have gained significant attention in recent years: Manaless Dredge and LED (Less Equipment Dredge). But which one is more resilient? Does better in tournament play? And are they both fun to play?

For the uninitiated, dredge decks rely on sacrificing creatures to generate card advantage through the 'dredge' mechanism. This mechanic allows players to dig deeper into their deck for powerful cards, often catching opponents off guard. While both Manaless Dredge and LED Dredge share this core strategy, there are key differences that set them apart.

Manaless Dredge, as its name suggests, eschews the traditional equipment-based approach of LED Dredge. Instead, it relies on a combination of creatures with built-in dredging abilities and cards that generate card advantage through other means. This flexibility allows Manaless Dredge to adapt to different metagames more easily, making it a formidable opponent in tournament play.

In contrast, LED Dredge is often characterized by its focus on equipment-based dredging. By sacrificing creatures equipped with powerful artifacts, players can generate massive amounts of card advantage and overwhelm their opponents. While this approach can be incredibly potent, it also leaves LED Dredge vulnerable to disruption from opposing removal spells or board wipes.

So, which one is more resilient? In a vacuum, Manaless Dredge's adaptability might give it an edge in terms of sheer survivability. However, when considering the current Legacy metagame, LED Dredge's equipment-based approach can be incredibly powerful against certain matchups.

In terms of tournament performance, both variants have seen success at the highest levels. In 2020, Manaless Dredge pilot Brad Nelson took down the Legacy Championship with a dominant 7-1 record. Meanwhile, LED Dredge has consistently produced top finishes in major tournaments, including a win at the 2019 Legacy Pro Tour.

Ultimately, whether or not both variants are fun to play depends on personal preference. If you enjoy the flexibility and adaptability of Manaless Dredge, it might be the better choice for you. However, if you're looking for a more explosive, equipment-based approach that can generate massive card advantage, LED Dredge could be the way to go.

In terms of advantages over its LED counterpart, Manaless Dredge offers several benefits. For one, its lack of equipment dependence makes it less vulnerable to disruption from removal spells or board wipes. Additionally, Manaless Dredge's adaptability allows it to respond more effectively to changing metagames and opponent strategies.

In conclusion, both Manaless Dredge and LED Dredge are formidable contenders in the Legacy format, each with its unique strengths and weaknesses. While Manaless Dredge's adaptability might give it an edge in terms of sheer survivability, LED Dredge's equipment-based approach can be incredibly powerful against certain matchups.

Whether you're a seasoned pro or just starting out in Legacy, both variants offer plenty of opportunities for creative deckbuilding and strategic gameplay. So why not give them a try? You never know – you might just find your new favorite deck!

Dredge manaless